Can Peyton Hillis Survive the Madden Curse?

Electronic Arts has a long history of selecting some of the highest-performing and best- known players to feature on the cover of its iconic football video game, Madden NFL. It also has an eerie history of featuring players on its cover that then go on to have seasons ranging from the sub-par to the career-ending. The “Madden Curse” is so well-known that players like LaDanian Tomlinson have even turned down the opportunity to be on the cover, fearing its repercussions. Can Madden NFL 12’s cover boy, Peyton Hillis, escape unscathed?
Hillis, a 25-year-old running back for the Cleveland Browns, isn’t what you would call a “superstar.” He rushed for 1,177 yards and 11 touchdowns in 2010, good enough for 11th and 6th places, respectively, among NFL running backs. He’s good, certainly, but there’s a long line of guys who ought to be on that cover before Hillis.
Hillis made the cover in a very Stephen Colbert-ian way: he won a not-exactly-representative fan vote. He was part of a bracket-style vote that had him beat Super Bowl MVP Aaron Rodgers, Ravens RB Ray Rice, and a series of higher-profile players, including Eagles QB Mike Vick in the finals. Support for Hillis came from all over the Web, especially from sites like ClevelandBrowns.com and a series of Hillis-for-the-cover websites that cropped up during the vote. He became an Internet favorite, and the vote tipped his way.
Hillis’ lack of superstar status might make him less prone to the Madden Curse: there’s not as far to fall, and he’s not in the mold of the traditional cover-gracing NFL athlete.
But history is history, and if history has anything to say about it the Madden Curse is very real. We’ve looked at the numbers, and we’ve found that video games really can predict the future. Or at least that Madden covers can predict NFL players’ demises. If the 14 guys in the slideshow are any indication, it’s time to dump Peyton Hillis from your fantasy team.